Given I'll be selling soon, thought I'd chime in.
First thing to keep in mind is that the markets are somewhat different, in different regions. So what is occurring here, or dynamics here, may not hold true "there". For the most part Trimmer is right (see below), but one thing he isn't mentioning is that buyers (and sellers) are more savy/in tune than they were X years ago.
But still suffer from the two most powerful motivators known to mankind.
Fear and Greed.
And the truth is, most people (the majority of the population) are inable to completely divest themselves from the decision making process and make cold, calculated, unemotional decisions. Especially when it comes to determining "what my house is worth". Using an extreme example for illustrative purposes...people get attached to their houses...It's where their children were born and grew up.....................Its where they sank $30,000 grand and hard labor into landscaping and or interlock or.....
Sometimes doesn't matter how much work a person puts into a house...A house is only worth what other people are willing to pay for it........,.....Example....Im sure back in 2008 many people were absolutely sure their houses were worth X.......Well when no-one is looking to buy....doesn't matter if you've sunk $400,000 in upgrades into it..Just ask residents of Florida....
Some agents do over inflate the market value to get the listings.....If you've done your own homework, or keep your thumb on the pulse in your area (I've followed my neighborhood for 5 years, know its highly sought after and there is very, very little turn over. <<<this makes it a little harder to get current values, but bodes well for me...Across the street a major artery homes are similar but turnover is high...theres always 2-5 homes for sale in that neighborhood, in mine..............only 1 or 2 in a year....You already have a reasonable idea. I have a reasonable idea, despite being trained to be emotionally detached, capable of divesting myself I know I will still have atleast some bias.
If the two agents I've interviewed are too far divergent from each other, and my own assessed value (which they aren't) in either direction well guess what...
Red flag
One of the worst things you can do as a seller especially these days (its a sellers market and there is very little inventory......is.....over.....price)....it will sit and sit and sit despite the lack of inventory. People know these things and when they see on the market for 21 days in these times.........
Red flag....as well