Originally Posted by
johny
Cut and paste from a recent review of Rotator Cuff Failure, in the New England Journal of Medicine.
NEJM is North Americas leading, premier, reputable medical journal:
It is unclear why some persons with rotator-cuff failure are symptomatic, whereas others with seemingly identical patterns of failure are asymptomatic. The optimal management of chronic degenerative rotator-cuff lesions remains uncertain, including the approach to exercise programs and the role of complementary therapies. It is unclear when surgical intervention is warranted; a survey of 539 orthopaedic surgeons showed remarkable inconsistency in perceptions about the indications for rotator-cuff surgery
In other words, nobody really knows the best interventional approach.
And that often means... stay away from surgeons... even if it takes a year or more... eventually it settles down and you'll be mostly OK again.